How to Create Lead Magnets That Actually Convert

A lead magnet is an offer: I'll give you something valuable; you give me your email address.

Most lead magnets fail to convert because they fail to be genuinely valuable. "Subscribe to our newsletter to receive our monthly insights" is not a lead magnet — it's an ask with no offer. A PDF titled "The Ultimate Guide to Marketing" that rehashes common knowledge is not valuable.

The best lead magnets solve a specific problem for a specific person — so completely that people are willing to trade their email for access.

This guide walks through how to create lead magnets that actually convert.

---

What Makes a Lead Magnet Convert

The best lead magnets share four characteristics:

Specific: "10 cold email templates that generated $2M in pipeline" beats "email templates." The more specific the promise, the higher the perceived value.

Immediately actionable: The user can use it right away. Templates, checklists, calculators, and frameworks are more immediately useful than long-form guides that require time to read.

Genuinely valuable: It should be something you'd be proud to sell (even if you're giving it away). If you wouldn't pay $10 for it, your prospects won't give you their email address for it.

Aligned with your product: The lead magnet should attract the same people who would buy your product. A "social media caption template" lead magnet on a content strategy platform attracts social media managers, not content strategists.

---

Step 1: Identify Your Ideal Subscriber's Most Urgent Problem

The best lead magnets solve the problem your ideal buyer is most urgently trying to solve right now.

How to find this:

Customer interviews: Ask your best customers: "What was the biggest problem you were trying to solve when you first found us? What resources or tools were you looking for?"

Sales conversation patterns: What questions do prospects ask most often in early sales conversations? What are they struggling with that your product helps with?

Content performance data: Which blog posts on your site get the most traffic? These topics are what your ICP is actively searching for — your best lead magnet opportunities are adjacent to your top-performing content.

Community observation: What questions come up repeatedly in your ICP's communities (Slack groups, subreddits, LinkedIn discussions)?

The intersection of "our ICP's most urgent problem" and "our product's core value proposition" is where your best lead magnet lives.

---

Step 2: Choose the Right Lead Magnet Format

Different formats work better for different purposes:

Templates: Provide a ready-to-use structure the user can immediately apply. Blog post templates, email sequence templates, content calendar templates. High perceived value, relatively fast to create.

Checklists: Break a complex process into actionable steps. "The 15-Point Content Audit Checklist." Easy to consume, immediately actionable. Work best for process-oriented topics.

Calculators or assessment tools: Interactive tools that produce a personalized result. An ROI calculator, a content audit scorecard, a "what content should you create" quiz. High engagement, memorable, often shared.

Swipe files: Collections of real examples. "17 subject lines with 50%+ open rates." "The exact outreach templates we used to land 40 backlinks." Highly specific, validated by real results.

Mini-courses or email sequences: 5–7 emails delivered over a week, each teaching one actionable concept. Good for complex topics that benefit from sequential learning. More commitment from the subscriber.

Reports and research: Original data about your market or category. More effort to produce but highly link-worthy and often cited by others.

Choose based on:

• What format best solves your ICP's specific problem
• What format your team can realistically produce well
• What format aligns with how your ICP prefers to learn

---

Step 3: Create the Lead Magnet

Design principle: substance over style.

A beautiful PDF with thin content will generate unsubscribes. A plain-text checklist with genuinely useful information generates referrals.

That said, presentation matters for perceived value. A template in a branded Google Doc looks more professional than one shared as raw text.

Production tips by format:

Templates: Build in Notion, Google Docs, or Airtable. Duplicate-able, instantly usable. Include clear instructions for each field.

Checklists: Google Docs or Notion. Each item should be specific and actionable, not vague. Include brief explanations for non-obvious items.

Calculators: Google Sheets (easy to duplicate), or a simple web-based tool if you have developer resources. Must produce a clear, personalized output.

Swipe files: Google Docs or Notion. Include the example AND a brief explanation of why it works. Context makes examples 10x more valuable.

Reports: Google Docs or designed PDF. Include executive summary, key findings, and methodology. Data sources and methodology build credibility.

Quality test: Would you be embarrassed to charge $29 for this? If not, it's not ready.

---

Step 4: Write Your Lead Magnet Landing Page

The landing page converts visitors into leads. It needs:

A specific headline: Not "Download our free guide" but "Get the exact content calendar template that helped 200+ startup marketing teams stay consistent all year."

Clear value bullets: What specifically will they get? What will they be able to do after?

A low-commitment CTA: "Get instant access," "Download now," "Send me the template" — low friction language. Avoid "Submit."

Social proof: A testimonial, a usage number, or a recognizable logo from someone who's used the resource.

Minimal form fields: Name + email is usually sufficient. Each additional field reduces conversion rate by 10–25%. Only ask for information you'll actually use.

Remove navigation: A dedicated landing page for a lead magnet should ideally remove the site navigation so visitors stay focused on the opt-in decision.

---

Step 5: Set Up Your Delivery and Follow-Up

Delivery:

• Immediately deliver the lead magnet via email after opt-in
• Also show a thank-you page with an immediate download link (people want it now, not just in email)
• If your lead magnet is a Notion page or Google Doc, give access via a shared link in the email

Follow-up sequence: Don't just deliver the lead magnet and go silent. Build a 3–5 email sequence:

Email 1 (immediate): Deliver the lead magnet + a brief note on how to get the most value from it.

Email 2 (day 2–3): A practical tip or insight related to the lead magnet topic. Establish expertise.

Email 3 (day 4–5): A case study or example related to the topic. Social proof.

Email 4 (day 6–7): A soft introduction to your product — "For those who want to go deeper, here's what Averi does and how it connects to what you learned in [lead magnet title]."

Email 5 (day 10–14): CTA to sign up or book a demo. By now they've received genuine value. A direct ask is earned.

---

Step 6: Promote Your Lead Magnet

Content integration: Embed your lead magnet CTA in related blog posts. If your lead magnet is a content calendar template, embed it in every post about content planning and editorial calendars.

Social media: Share on LinkedIn and Twitter/X with a "direct download" feel — screenshot of the resource, link to the landing page. Run ads against it if you have budget.

Existing audience: Email your current subscribers about the new resource. Many will share it.

Community sharing: Share in relevant Slack communities, subreddits, and forums where your ICP hangs out. Don't just drop a link — provide context and value.

Partnerships: Ask partners, collaborators, or complementary companies to share your lead magnet with their audiences.

---

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Asking for too much: Name, company, job title, phone number, and email in a form for a free PDF is too much friction. Name + email converts best.

Delivering a lead magnet that doesn't match the promise: If your headline says "10 templates" and the download contains 10 variations of one template, you've eroded trust on the first contact.

No follow-up sequence: Without a follow-up sequence, most lead magnet downloads become one-time downloads and nothing else. The sequence is where the relationship gets built.

Not promoting it consistently: A lead magnet that's only in the footer converts no one. Embed CTAs prominently in related content and promote actively.

---

How Averi Helps

Creating a lead magnet is one thing. Creating the landing page copy, the follow-up email sequence, and the blog posts that drive traffic to it is the real production challenge. Averi helps you build the entire lead magnet funnel — from the landing page to the nurture sequence — in your brand voice.

Many teams use Averi to produce both the lead magnet content itself (templates, checklists, guides) and the surrounding conversion copy, dramatically reducing the time from idea to live campaign.

Build your lead magnet funnel →

---

FAQ

What's the best lead magnet for a B2B SaaS company?

Templates, calculators, and diagnostic tools tend to convert best for B2B SaaS. They're immediately actionable, genuinely useful, and attract buyers at the right awareness stage. Original research performs well for thought leadership but takes more effort to produce.

How many lead magnets should I have?

Start with 1–2 that each target different stages of your funnel (one for early awareness, one for consideration-stage). Build the distribution for those before creating more. Having 10 poorly-promoted lead magnets is worse than 2 well-promoted ones.

Should I gate my lead magnet behind an email wall?

For most lead magnets, yes — that's the point. But consider: how much barrier is reasonable? A piece of lightweight content that's available widely elsewhere doesn't need a gate. Reserve gating for content that's genuinely exclusive and valuable.

How do I know if my lead magnet is converting well?

A 20–30% conversion rate on your lead magnet landing page is healthy (people who visit the page and opt in). Below 10% suggests a problem with either the offer or the landing page copy.

How do I keep lead magnet subscribers engaged after they opt in?

With a high-quality nurture sequence and consistent, valuable newsletter content. Subscribers who opted in for a specific resource are primed to receive relevant content. If your regular email program is valuable, they'll stay engaged.